Tag Archive for 'logic'

The geographic and temporal spread argument, part 18

(Part 17 is here.)

In my experience, whenever I have raised these problems with religious believers, the explanations they have come up with have always missed the point. An expert in the history of the ancient Near East can indeed come up with an elaborate hypothesis as to why there is so little evidence for David and Solomon. A Muslim apologist can indeed assert that the Biblical account of Solomon is corrupted where it contradicts or lacks details given in the Qur’an. Yes, you can cook up theories that agree with your religious beliefs to fit the evidence (or, even better, which ignore the evidence). But then the theory is only meaningful for someone who already accepts that your religion is true, or special, to begin with. If you want your argument to be convincing to someone who is not already a believer, you have to explain why it cannot be applied just as well to another, and possibly conflicting, religion.

Here is a theory that fits the evidence: the Biblical accounts of David and Solomon’s splendour are simply made-up… » [Expand post] [Permalink]

0 Comments

The geographic and temporal spread argument, part 8

(Part 7 is here.)

Indeed, a demonstration of omniscience to a being who is not himself or herself omniscient is impossible. As limited humans, we have no way even in principle of verifying whether or not another being is omniscient. This is a problem that the early Buddhists were already aware of, and they made use of it in their arguments and polemics against theistic religions… » [Expand post] [Permalink]

0 Comments

A message for college and university students regarding Clubs Days

The following is an article I wrote for Clubs Days. I’m also going to condense it into a pamphlet on paper, which I’m going to hand out.


If you’re a college or university student, it’s the beginning of a new school year, which means that there will probably be some kind of event to introduce you and the various student organisations on campus to each other. This event is typically called “Clubs Days” (or “Clubs Week”). And whether there’s such a formal event or not, you will undoubtedly be approached by members of numerous religious, political, and other interest groups who will try to convert you to their points of view.

College or university is a time of exploration, and I strongly encourage you to consider and examine the ideas that you encounter… » [Expand post] [Permalink]

No related posts.

0 Comments

Gifted program in Mississauga

In Mississauga, we were enrolled in a gifted program at a Catholic elementary school, because our mother is a Roman Catholic. They had a pretty nice library there, and because the school was Catholic, there were lots of books on Latin, Greek, Roman history, and Catholicism, and I became interested in those subjects.

I had actually been reading the Bible in English since my arrival in Canada. My grandparents were given a copy when they were sworn in as citizens. Since they couldn’t read it, they said I could have it, and I used to read it every day. In grade five, the Gideons came to our public school — in fact, into our classroom with the teacher’s permission — and gave each of the students a pocket edition of the New Testament with Psalms and Proverbs, with a red leathery cover. I used to carry it everywhere and read it whenever I had the chance. Nowadays that sort of blatant proselytism of immigrants and children would probably not be allowed inside a public institution. But I don’t think that I was ever harmed by it — in fact, quite the opposite. By studying the Bibles, I not only learned about Protestantism and other sects of Christianity, but also vastly improved my vocabulary, became familiar with archaic and other literary forms of English, and began to think about problems of translation between languages. So I don’t think the Bible should be kept out of public classrooms, as some people do — it is one of the most important documents in Western civilisation, regardless of one’s beliefs about it, and one can learn a lot from it… » [Expand post] [Permalink]

4 Comments